The 'Christmas effect': It may not be healthy to go home from the hospital for the holidays, U of T study finds
Hospital patients yearn to be home for the holidays, but discharging them may not be good for their health, a new University of Toronto study suggests.
The study, led by Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation PhD student Lauren Lapointe-Shaw, has found that patients discharged from hospital during the two-week period over the holidays are at a higher risk of death within the first seven days of discharge and are more likely to be re-admitted to hospital within 30 days.
The study, published in The BMJ, also found that patients were less likely to receive a followup from their physician after discharge during the holidays versus other times of the year.
“Based on our understanding of what might be occurring, we can see there are a few possibilities,” said Lapointe-Shaw, who is also a Philipson Scholar in the Department of Medicine’s Clinician-Scientist Training Program and clinical associate at Toronto General Hospital. “As with many services during the holidays, an individual’s family physician may be more difficult to access during this time, or patients themselves might be choosing to wait to schedule a followup because they are involved in holiday activities.”
Lapointe-Shaw and fellow researchers studied patient populations discharged into the community between 2002 and 2016 using data from the Institute of Clinical Evaluative Sciences. These patients were then compared to those discharged during the control periods of November and January.Those discharged the week before or the week after Christmas, regardless of age, were at an increased risk of death or hospital readmission. This also included a higher risk of returning to urgent care and emergency departments.
Per 100,000 patients, there were 26 excess deaths, 188 excess re-hospitalizations and 483 excess visits to an emergency department that could be attributed to discharge over the holiday period, according to the study.
“There were limitations to our study,” said Lapointe-Shaw, “and we can’t say for certain why some of these outcomes are being observed, including why patients do not return for followups. However I think there is enough evidence in the study to encourage both health-care providers and patients to pay closer attention to discharge planning.”
Discharge planning is a key focus of Lapointe-Shaw’s dissertation research. As a physician, she says her interest was piqued after witnessing the effects of good and inadequate discharge planning on her patients. Discharge planning often begins when the individual is being admitted to hospital, and includes determining patient stability, identifying all medications, and educating the patient on a plan to follow if new symptoms arise.
“As physicians it is important for us to pay additional attention to discharge planning and for outpatient providers to ensure that patients don’t fall through cracks when resources are strained,” said Lapointe-Shaw. “For Ontarians, I think it is great to see this level of interest in the issue of coverage in health care over the holidays. Changes have already been implemented in family physician clinics, and in the next few years we will need to see what kinds of results these changes have yielded in terms of our patient outcomes.”
For the rest of the public and for patients who may be discharged over the holidays, this study emphasizes the need to remain well-informed of their discharge plan and follow the recommendations of their physicians for additional checkups as needed.
